Chris, Steffen,
There are certainly packages that do the same thing as Stats and Banners, with many more features. But not everybody needs those extra features.
Plus, outside packages need to be installed, maintained, themed, and provide an added security risk to deal with.
Banners is a simple module integrated with Zikula, that fulfills a simple need. Stats provides a simple, integrated solution to give some quick eye candy statistics to your visitors.
With PostNuke, the idea was to provide a whole bunch of integrated add-ons for your website that were quick and easy to use. The
PN package gave you a complete, working website out of the box. Many people would just add forums and a gallery, and would have all they needed
Zikula's come a long way since then, but certain things have changed. You couldn't recommend it to a beginner at this time. It's powerful and flexible, but you have to spend a lot more time building your site before you achieve your aims. Plus, at the present time, it looks pretty mediocre right out of the box. I'm sure these things will change over time.
But I think it's a pity not to maintain some of those old modules in at least working condition... They were simple, working solutions to immediate needs.
Anyway, I know the design outlook of the devs has changed totally from the original aims of
PN. But look at the community that was lost. Many of the new design aims are merit-worthy but,
IMHO, in some respects the project took its eye off the ball and forgot some basic considerations.
Me, personally, I love using Zikula and I'm building 3 sites at this time. But many people don't feel the same.
--
David
http://zikula.tv